But there are still plenty of reasons why you might want to buy the Xbox One X anyway, over Sony’s PS4 Pro.
Microsoft Xbox One X Introduction
The Xbox One X is Microsoft’s first proper 4K games console. It will sit alongside the Xbox One S, which also has a 4K Blu-ray drive for UHD movie playback, but can only play games at 1080p resolution.
In terms of the UI and what you can do with the console, the Microsoft Xbox One X is pretty much identical to the One S; yes, it looks a little different, but switch it on and you’ll forget all about that. The key difference is more power underneath, plus support for gaming at 4K and HDR, which means sharper graphics, frame rates and a richer colour palette.
To enable all that, there’s more power squeezed inside the Xbox One X than any other games console around, with a quoted 6TFLOPS of computing power – compared with the PS4 Pro’s 4.2TFLOPS – 12GB of GDDR5 RAM with 326MB/sec of bandwidth, 8GB of flash storage plus a 1TB internal hard disk.
Design and the hardware
The Xbox One X is a subtle design. It doesn’t look flashy or even particularly exciting, but it’s compact – around the same size as the One S – it’s quiet and has all the connectivity you’d expect.
The front and left side is stepped with a short overhang obscuring the Blu-ray drive slot on the left side, there’s a front-mounted USB 3 socket and two further on the rear, plus a pair of HDMI sockets - one is for connecting your set-top box; while the other is an HDMI 2.0 output for connecting the console to your TV. An optical S/PDIF port makes another appearance, which gives plenty of flexibility to those preferring that type of output, or who have a wireless headphone.
It’s all 4K 60Hz compatible, so whatever your source can output, the Xbox One X should be able to pass that straight through. The box itself supports HDR10, which is the most common form of HDR. It would have been nice to have Dolby Vision as well, which supports higher peak brightness and dynamic range than HDR10, but for now the Xbox One X covers most of the HDR-enabled TV’s on the market. Assuming you have a compatible TV, like the Samsung UE65KS9500 I tested the Xbox One X with, you’ll see both richer colours and brighter specular highlights.
See also: Samsung UE65KS9500 Full Review
Microsoft also promotes the console’s ability to support Dolby Atmos on its website, which is very much a GOOD THING. It’s worth underlining, though, that this is not only for 4K Blu-rays and streamed TV and movie content, but also those enhanced games (more on that later).
One thing the Xbox One X doesn’t bring is any kind of improvement on the controller front; in fact, you get exactly the same Bluetooth-enabled controller in the box as comes with the Xbox One S. It’s a great controller, but it would have been nice to see some features trickling down from the Xbox Elite controller, such as rear-mounted paddles or a rechargeable battery pack as standard.
Also see: PS4 Pro Review
4K performance and games content
4k games, so how they look and how they play. The answer to the second part of that question is “exceptionally”. Play Gears of War 4, Super Lucky’s Tale or FIFA 18 side by side with the same titles on a One S and the differences are obvious.
It’s important to note that not all enhanced games will run in native 4K. Some will run with checkerboarding like the PS4 Pro and some will offer enhanced frame rates while others will use the power of the new console to offer dynamic resolution, increased texture detail and higher polygon counts.
In the end, it’s up to the developer to decide how to optimise for the One X, but all the games I’ve installed so far play more smoothly, look more colourful and pack cleaner, crisper and sharper visuals across the board on the One X. When you go back to the same games on the One S you’ll wonder where all the detail went.
As far as Blu-ray video content goes, it looks just as good as it ever did on the Xbox One S with settings for 8-bit, 10-bit and 12-bit output, depending on what your TV supports.
As with all 4K content, however, the trouble is that although the smoother gameplay and colours are obvious from any distance, as soon as you sit a reasonable distance away from your TV, the extra detail that 4K brings just fades away. Everything looks great from my armchair a metre away from my 55in Hisense M7000, but as soon as I go to sit on the sofa and play, those differences become less apparent.
Xbox One X 1TB Console
The other issue for Microsoft is that the number of fully 4K-optimised games available at launch isn’t good at all. At launch, Microsoft’s first-party games support is slim, with just Disneyland Adventures, Rush: A Disney-Pixar Adventure, Zoo Tycoon Ultimate Animal Collection, Super Lucky’s Tale, Killer Instinct, Gears of War 4, Halo 5 Guardians and Halo 3. Microsoft really need to step up their game and I'm sure there will be more 4k games coming soon, especially in time for christmas.
The big headliners, such as Forza Motorsport 7 won’t get 4K enhancements until after launch, although having played a pre-release version at a preview event I can confirm that it looks absolutely gorgeous.
On the third-party front, only a light scattering of titles is ready for launch day. FIFA 18 is the headliner here, but there’s not much else worth mentioning, so that means no Assassin’s Creed Origins or Call of Duty: WWII in 4K on day one. Don’t panic, they are coming, just not yet.
It must be said that the same was true of Sony’s 4K library when the PS4 Pro launched but, even so, there were a few more titles available on launch day than this. And, of course, Sony does have a year’s head start here, so there’s a much larger current selection of games than is available for the Xbox One X.
Still, as more developers begin to release patches for existing games, this landscape should change soon. Microsoft says there are 130 titles confirmed as “Xbox One X Enhanced” and more will follow throughout 2018.
Price and competition
It’s hardly surprising to find that the Xbox One X is pricey, but the fact that it costs £450, which is £100 more than the Sony PS4 Pro, could very well prove its undoing. Sony’s effort doesn’t have a 4K Blu-ray drive or offer true 4K gaming but its chequerboard technique does ensure enhanced titles still look great.
The Xbox One X’s main competition comes from within, in the form of the Xbox One S. That console is less than half the price of the One X and there are some pretty tempting bundle deals around at the moment for less than £200.
The One S is compatible with all the same titles as the One X and is a capable console in its own right. Even though it can "only" play games in 1080p, it has support for HDR gaming with some enhanced titles and there’s still a 4K Blu-ray drive built in, so you can at least watch your favourite movies in ultra-high definition.
Xbox One X 1TB Console
Microsoft Xbox One X Review: Verdict
Should you buy the Xbox One X? The answer at this early stage is, well, possibly. It all boils down to what you have right now, whether you’re desperate for 4K games and whether you’re up for spending this much on a games console that doesn’t offer a huge amount extra over and above a console costing half as much.
If you’re an Xbox devotee and already own a One, then it’s a tempting proposition. Not only do you get 4K gaming, but you also get a Blu-ray player that’s as good as most dedicated decks at the same price.
What it does offer, however, is futureproofing. There is no doubt that the "world's most powerful console" will get the software it deserves in 2018 and beyond. As developers become used to the sheer grunt under the hood, the games will surpass versions for any other machine on the market. The boasting rights then will be something to behold.
If you don't have an Xbox already, it’s much less clear-cut. Yes, if you want 4K Blu-ray playback and 4K gaming, the One X is the way to go. It’s certainly cheaper than paying for a PS4 Pro and a Blu-ray player separately. But if games are your focus, the larger 4K-enabled games library and lower price of the PS4 Pro would be the way to go.
As ever, your final decision should really rest on the games you want to play. If you’re a big fan of Forza, or Gears of War then yes, buy an Xbox One X. It’s a great piece of hardware and 4K games look great on it. In our opinion, everyone else, should opt for the PS4 Pro.